Eli-Peyton Comparison

Since it seems like it will be a hot topic I thought I'd actually look up the stats.


Eli Mannings First 8 Seasons:
Regular Season-
119 Games Started
69-50 Record
2291-3921 58.4%
27,579 Yards
185 TD (4.7%)
129 INT (3.3%)
82.1 Rating
20 Fourth Quarter Comebacks
24 Game Winning Drives

Eli Manning Playoffs:
8-3 Record
219- 356 61.5%
2520 Yards
17TD (4.7%)
8INT (2.2%)
90.9 Rating
2 Fourth Quarter Comebacks
3 Game Winning Drives
2 Super Bowl Wins

Peyton Manning First 8 Seasons:
Regular Season
80-48 Record
2769-4333 63.9%
33,189 Yards
244 TD (5.6%)
130 INT (3.0%)
93.5 Rating
19 Fourth Quarter Comebacks
25 Game Winning Drives

Peyton Manning First 8 Season Playoffs
3-6 Record
193-321 60.1%
2,462 Yards
15 TD (4.6%)
8 INT (2.4%)
89.3 Rating
0 Fourth Quarter Comebacks
0 Game Winning Drives
0 Super Bowl Appearances


Regular Season is clearly Peyton, but Postseason is clearly Eli. It will be interesting to see how Eli does from here on out.

Peyton please come back. I cant take these comparisons anymore.

S-UNIT302 wrote:Peyton please come back. I cant take these comparisons anymore.

LOL I did it to kill some time and actually see if its justified in comparing them. It really isn't unless you look at postseason.

MaddMatt wrote:

S-UNIT302 wrote:Peyton please come back. I cant take these comparisons anymore.

LOL I did it to kill some time and actually see if its justified in comparing them. It really isn't unless you look at postseason.

No fuck you and your stupid comparisons. Eli doesn't win yesterday if he has a bad defense like the Patriots

Peyton and Eli are two different types of qbs.

Eli is absolutely no emotion with a "fuck it, I dont care" face while peyton is almost like captain ahab from Moby Dick with a complete obsession over 1 fucking thing.