Current HOF players?

In commemoration of the HOF, this got me thinking about current players. Pick 5 current players that if they did NOT play another snap, they deserve to be in the HOF. Let's say Brett Favre and Randy Moss are retired!

1. Tom Brady
2. Peyton Manning
3. Tony Gonzalez
4. Ray Lewis
5. Brian Urlacher

On the Bubble:

LT and Hines Ward

manning
brady
sharper (most int returns)
hester? maybe his special teams impact made a difference on the game, everybody loves him.
tillman. he deserves something, if not a bust but something in the hall

Mark Sanchez FTW!!!!!


anyways, on to the mere mortals

Polamalu
Reed
Manning
brady
andre johnson ( will have over 10,000 yds recieving this year)
Rothisberger ( rings get people into the HOF)
LT (if he retired 2 yrs ago he wouldve went in, these last couple just icing on cake)
Ray Lewis ( joins another murderer, OJ)
AP ( best HB in the game since he joined league, worst season he had 1298 yrds )
Gates
Gonzo
.....................bubblicious...Wes Welker ( 3 more 1000 yd season from the slot will punch his ticket)

MASTRxOFxPUPPETZ wrote:Mark Sanchez FTW!!!!!


anyways, on to the mere mortals

Polamalu
Reed
Manning
brady
andre johnson ( will have over 10,000 yds recieving this year)
Rothisberger ( rings get people into the HOF)
LT (if he retired 2 yrs ago he wouldve went in, these last couple just icing on cake)
Ray Lewis ( joins another murderer, OJ)
AP ( best HB in the game since he joined league, worst season he had 1298 yrds )
Gates
Gonzo
.....................bubblicious...Wes Welker ( 3 more 1000 yd season from the slot will punch his ticket)

he asked for 5 but thank you

Ray Lewis - Best MLB in NFL history IMO. Lead one of the best defenses in NFL history and won a Superbowl.

Tony Gonzalez - I think this man has every TE record in the league, and probably a few WR records. If that's not enough to get in, I don't know what is.

Ladanien Tomlinson - One of the best backs in league history. I think he has the most rushing TDs in a single season. At least at one point he did.

Payton Manning - I believe he has four league MVPs now, a Superbowl MVP, IMO the best regular season QB ever.

Tom Brady - 3 rings, 50 tds in a single season, the most clutch QB in the history of the league. This man makes chicken salad out of chicken shit every single year. His 3 Superbowl wins were all with crap WRs. In my honest oppinion, when it's all said and done, he will be the best QB to ever play the game.

The scary part is, Brady and Manning still have years left.

I know you said to keep it to players still playing but i'm going to name some one else who just retired last offseason and also because everyone worthy right now had been said or i cant remember them


Seahawks LT Walter Jones... One of, if not, the best offensive tackles to play the game. Guy was a monster on the offensive line... a true beast. He should be a first ballot HOFer and if it isnt i'll cry east coast bias.

In no order:

Brady
Manning
Tomlinson
Ed Reed
Adam Vineteri - they need more kickers in the Hall.

Brady
Manning
L.T.
Lewis
Reed

ward
peterson ya i know his career is still young but he is just incredible.
owens
brees
farrior ok meybe that one is just me being a homer but he has been the leader of the steelers defenses which have been great and won superbowls.

can this be any time? or current. If any time, I'll say Revis too when he gets older and ready to retire..

BaltRavensFan20 wrote:can this be any time? or current. If any time, I'll say Revis too when he gets older and ready to retire..

Read my first post haha. It says if they didn't EVER play another snap in their life.

legendkiller716 wrote:Ray Lewis - Best MLB in NFL history IMO. Lead one of the best defenses in NFL history and won a Superbowl.

Tony Gonzalez - I think this man has every TE record in the league, and probably a few WR records. If that's not enough to get in, I don't know what is.

Ladanien Tomlinson - One of the best backs in league history. I think he has the most rushing TDs in a single season. At least at one point he did.

Payton Manning - I believe he has four league MVPs now, a Superbowl MVP, IMO the best regular season QB ever.

Tom Brady - 3 rings, 50 tds in a single season, the most clutch QB in the history of the league. This man makes chicken salad out of chicken shit every single year. His 3 Superbowl wins were all with crap WRs. In my honest oppinion, when it's all said and done, he will be the best QB to ever play the game.

The scary part is, Brady and Manning still have years left.

Agreed with this list completely.

at23steelers wrote:

BaltRavensFan20 wrote:can this be any time? or current. If any time, I'll say Revis too when he gets older and ready to retire..

Read my first post haha. It says if they didn't EVER play another snap in their life.

yeah, maybe not revis just yet then....

Soarindude02 wrote:

legendkiller716 wrote:Ray Lewis - Best MLB in NFL history IMO. Lead one of the best defenses in NFL history and won a Superbowl.

Tony Gonzalez - I think this man has every TE record in the league, and probably a few WR records. If that's not enough to get in, I don't know what is.

Ladanien Tomlinson - One of the best backs in league history. I think he has the most rushing TDs in a single season. At least at one point he did.

Payton Manning - I believe he has four league MVPs now, a Superbowl MVP, IMO the best regular season QB ever.

Tom Brady - 3 rings, 50 tds in a single season, the most clutch QB in the history of the league. This man makes chicken salad out of chicken shit every single year. His 3 Superbowl wins were all with crap WRs. In my honest oppinion, when it's all said and done, he will be the best QB to ever play the game.

The scary part is, Brady and Manning still have years left.

Agreed with this list completely.

Now that I look at it I really do like this list..

McNabb
Fitzgerald

I would like to see ocho cinco to make the HOF just to listen to his speech

MyDirtyDangles wrote:I would like to see ocho cinco to make the HOF just to listen to his speech

after his time with the patriots? i bet it be boring

"id like to thank coach belichick and tom brady blah blah blah"

EpicxPlatypus69 wrote:

MyDirtyDangles wrote:I would like to see ocho cinco to make the HOF just to listen to his speech

after his time with the patriots? i bet it be boring

"id like to thank coach belichick and tom brady blah blah blah"

im in heaven with my prius....

legendkiller716 wrote:Ray Lewis - Best MLB in NFL history IMO. Lead one of the best defenses in NFL history and won a Superbowl.

Tony Gonzalez - I think this man has every TE record in the league, and probably a few WR records. If that's not enough to get in, I don't know what is.

Ladanien Tomlinson - One of the best backs in league history. I think he has the most rushing TDs in a single season. At least at one point he did.

Payton Manning - I believe he has four league MVPs now, a Superbowl MVP, IMO the best regular season QB ever.

Tom Brady - 3 rings, 50 tds in a single season, the most clutch QB in the history of the league. This man makes chicken salad out of chicken shit every single year. His 3 Superbowl wins were all with crap WRs. In my honest oppinion, when it's all said and done, he will be the best QB to ever play the game.

The scary part is, Brady and Manning still have years left.

This is about as definite as it gets,but if I had to pick someone from the Cowboys it would have to be Witten.