Brady or Rodgers

So we sparked a debate a work today.

Would you rather have Aaron Rodgers or Tom Brady at QB?

We've always had the Manning-Brady debate but we've never really put Brady up against other QB's such as Rodgers.

So let me ask you:


You have a must win game, who do you go with Aaron Rodgers or Tom Brady


Sidenote: I can no longer say Aaron without saying A-A- ron, Thanks Key and Peele

A-A ron all day if he's healthy. I feel like if he was 100% last night, he would be in the Super Bowl

HurpDurpHurray wrote:A-A ron all day if he's healthy. I feel like if he was 100% last night, he would be in the Super Bowl

Interesting.

I'm taking Brady all day.

Brady 20-8 in the playoffs
Rodgers is 6-5.

Also Rodgers has gone 1 and done, three times in the playoffs, Brady twice, Peyton like 8 lol

The thing is, I just trust Brady more in the playoffs, he usually always finds a way to win.

Rodgers, he has a better arm, more accurate, very mobile, basically if you were to build a qb in a lab, he would be it

tough one...as much as i Hate to say it, imma take Brady...the guy has excelled at the position all his life, hes fiery and emotional..thats what a leader does to get his teamates pumped up and make sure everyone is playing at a high level, Rodgers doesnt do that, sure hes a good QB but i kinda get a little of the "me first" attitude from him and the "oh well we were the better team but lost" from him as well..Brady demands excellence from his teammates and gets results...gimme Brady and a WR corp that nobody has ever heard of before, he gets results.

In their prime?

Hmm Brady.

Why pick over yesterdays leftovers when you have this.

" />

Willbacker wrote:Why pick over yesterdays leftovers when you have this.

" />

THAT'S NOT THE QUESTION!

Although, it is funny that Flacco has more playoff wins than Rodgers, with a worse offense (no offense to Baltimores offense, but GB weapons> Baltimore weapons)

MaddMatter wrote:

Willbacker wrote:Why pick over yesterdays leftovers when you have this.

" />

THAT'S NOT THE QUESTION!

Although, it is funny that Flacco has more playoff wins than Rodgers, with a worse offense (no offense to Baltimores offense, but GB weapons> Baltimore weapons)

Defense.

S wrote:

MaddMatter wrote:

Willbacker wrote:Why pick over yesterdays leftovers when you have this.

" />

THAT'S NOT THE QUESTION!

Although, it is funny that Flacco has more playoff wins than Rodgers, with a worse offense (no offense to Baltimores offense, but GB weapons> Baltimore weapons)

Defense.

Good point, but still, Flacco just went something like 15-2 in TD-INT ratio.

Either way, this is on Rodgers Brady

MaddMatter wrote:

S wrote:

MaddMatter wrote:

Willbacker wrote:Why pick over yesterdays leftovers when you have this.

" />

THAT'S NOT THE QUESTION!

Although, it is funny that Flacco has more playoff wins than Rodgers, with a worse offense (no offense to Baltimores offense, but GB weapons> Baltimore weapons)

Defense.

Good point, but still, Flacco just went something like 15-2 in TD-INT ratio.

Either way, this is on Rodgers Brady

Well if I have to choose for 2nd best I'd have to go with crybrady. He has taken his team to 4 straight AFC championship games with less but the funny thing is I still think Rodgers is the best in the game. I'm not joking about Flacco tho he still my playoff QB.

Montana

4-0 in super bows
11 tds - 0 ints